Specialty cheeses

Our specialty cheeses go the extra mile to bring unique flavors to your table. These varieties include cheddars with an extra dose of tender loving care and a cave-ripened cheese unique to our farm, the fabled Le Cheval.

Farmstead Flight Sampler

Farmstead Fresh Flight Sampler

Real Milk Cheese is proud to partner with Farmstead Fresh to bring you their delicious cheeses at an amazing price. The flight sampler is the go to sampler for those that want to mix things up. It has all of the classic Farmstead Fresh cheeses so you will leave no curd unturned with this one. There are 13 cheeses in this sampler, meaning you could have a different cheese each day straight for almost 2 weeks!

Flight Sampler

Flight Sampler

To make your parties and events special, we're offering a discounted Flight Sampler that includes one half pound block of each of our varieties of cheese. Liven up that party table and stuff those gift baskets with a treat that only gets better if it gets old.

Ultimate Sampler

Ultimate Sampler

Our Ultimate Sampler includes three 8 oz. blocks of each of our classic cheeses AND two 8oz. blocks of our specialty varieties: Cheddar, Colby, Pepper Jack, Aged Cheddar, and the perennial favorite Smoked Cheddar!

Ultimate Samplers ship within the 48 contiguous states, but we can't promise your delivery driver won't crack it open with a bottle of bubbly on the way to your house.

Smoked Cheddar Cheese

Raw Milk Smoked Cheddar Cheese

One of the many secrets of the best Amish cheesemongers is how to smoke a cheese to perfection. This is our hottest variety, a personal favorite, and one taste will show you why.

This cheese is very sweet and creamy but delivers a delicious smoked flavor that tickles your savory taste buds as well.

Aged Cheddar Cheese

Raw Milk Aged Cheddar Cheese

If the old adage that "cheddar is better" still holds true, then how much better is Aged Cheddar? If you thought our classic cheddar was the acme of Cheesedom, you are in for a real treat... our aged cheddar cheese packs an even more deliciously complex punch.

Subscribe to RSS - Specialty cheeses